How to Make an Impossible Decision (With Examples)

Updated

Indecision feels miserable. Everywhere you turn, you feel trapped by the choices in front of you. Your stress builds and pressure mounts. How will you ever get through this impossible, life-changing choice? 

Hard decisions are part of creating a meaningful life for yourself. The time you take wrestling with these issues helps define who you are. But if you’re unprepared, a hard choice can seem like an impossible puzzle with no right answer.

That’s kind of the trick, finding the right answer. Part of making hard decisions is defining what works for you as you make your choice. Is there an absolute right answer for every situation? Maybe, but maybe not. 

This guide will take you through some helpful tips for making a hard choice. As you shift your mindset, you’ll learn how to see hard choices as opportunities for growth.

1. Dealing With Uncertainty 

Does uncertainty make you uncomfortable? If so, you aren’t alone. Uncertainty can make people feel like a failure for not knowing the right course of action. Perhaps you feel like uncertainty is a sign that things are about to go wrong. It’s easy to fall into this trap, but your emotions don’t always tell you the right story.

Uncertainty is a normal part of everyday life. You’ll rarely get a day when everything goes your way. You already know how to handle small unexpected problems at work and at home. You probably handle dozens of these every day without realizing it. When you look at it that way, you may feel more confident about handling uncertainty on a bigger scale.

Moments of uncertainty can make you freeze up, especially if you feel fear or embarrassment. Instead, try to see these as opportunities to try something new. When uncertainty arises, your creative mind can kick into gear.

You can connect dots and see options that weren’t apparent before. Embracing uncertainty gives you the emotional freedom to see your hard decision in a new light.

ยป CAKE FOR ENTERPRISE: Leading health care organizations know the future of advance care planning is digital. Partner with Cake to create your digital solution.

 

2. There May Not Be a 'Best Choice' 

Ruth Chang, professor of philosophy at Rutgers University, says that we often look at difficult choices as if they can be measured and compared directly. In reality, some choices are on par with each other. The outcomes may be very different, but no single choice is superior.

Instead, take a stand for one of the choices and create reasons for why that choice works. For example, If you like two houses that could both work, rally behind one of them and show yourself why that’s the house for you. The reasons for choosing one particular house help define who you are as a person. The value you create to justify that choice is part of what you stand for.

We often dread hard choices, but Chang says these are golden opportunities to define what you stand for and what makes you unique. This reframe of hard choices can make the process less intimidating and easier to live with.

3. Simplify the Picture to Avoid Becoming Overwhelmed 

Some decisions may seem hard because you’re trying to solve too many problems at once. Imagine you got two job offers, one across the country and another one a few hours away. You might feel overwhelmed with everything involved in choosing the best job offer. Where do you start?

Consider what you value when moving to a new city. How important is your living arrangement or your commute? Is one job considerably different from the other one? You might not mind certain aspects but feel picky about others. Prioritize a few critical elements and push aside the rest for now.

Focus on your top priorities and see how your choices match up with each one. Once you get rid of the clutter, you may feel more relaxed about making your decision. 

4. Beware of the Sunk Cost Fallacy 

The sunk cost fallacy is a cognitive bias that causes you to base future decisions on past investment. You’re willing to give up a lot of opportunities to avoid losing something. In fact, you’re so inclined to avoid losing that you’ll step over perfectly good options to get to the safe bet. 

This scenario explains how the sunk cost fallacy works. You want to break up with your partner because your relationship doesn’t work anymore. You want to find someone who’s more mature and a better fit for your life. But since you’ve spent seven years with them, you allow things to continue. You feel unhappy and have wanted to break up before, but the time you’ve invested in the relationship always stops you short. 

Think of it this way: if you met this person today with the qualities they have, would you choose them as a partner? If the answer is no, then the sunk cost fallacy is influencing your decision instead of your true interests.  

5. Avoid Getting Stuck on Feelings 

When faced with a difficult decision, you may feel a little stress or anxiety. That’s normal, but emotions can complicate the process if you don’t manage them well. It’s easy to get distracted by emotion, so find ways to stay calm and focused through the process.

  • Have a friend or your partner check on your emotion now and then. Get your concerns off your chest and deal with them so you can keep moving forward.
  • Avoid making decisions when you are noticeably emotional or stressed. Unless it’s life or death, calm down first before sorting your options. Your choices will look different with more or less emotion.
  • Understand that feelings come and go. They aren’t a good way to measure the quality of your decision, either. Even good decisions can stir up mixed feelings. 
  • Don’t always trust your gut. Be sure you have solid information to base a decision on first.
  • If you have time to sleep on a decision, do it. A refreshed mind will do a better job of sorting out the options than a frazzled, tired one.

6. Many Decisions Can Be Changed, Even Big Ones 

When you see choices as permanent, unchangeable paths, it’s easy to feel frozen. Why would you lock yourself into a bad choice for the rest of your life? If your mind is in knots over a big decision, try a different viewpoint.

Many decisions can be changed in some way, even big ones. Some choices will alter your life significantly, but you can take steps to work around problems. Encourage yourself to see decisions as a little more flexible, and you’ll take some pressure off your mind. 

Realizing this also helps you avoid making decisions out of fear. Fear-driven choices can put you in the wrong direction. While some choices cannot be undone, many can be. Reversing your course can be frustrating and time-consuming. But seeing the wrong choice as the end of the world can freeze up your mind. Allow yourself some slack as you move through the process.

7. Get Another Perspective or Two 

Do you need advice or do you need emotional support? Sometimes another perspective helps you see things more clearly; other times you need better information. Maybe you just need someone to listen and support you as you work through things. 

Get help from someone who can stay emotionally steady. You have emotion tied up in this decision, so a mature, reliable friend or mentor is ideal. Help them understand their role with you. If you need specialized advice, choose someone with experience and training.

It’s OK to consult more than one person if they provide different help for you. You might ask a friend in your career field about different job choices, and ask a financial advisor for budgeting advice. But bringing in too many viewpoints can be confusing, so be sure you know why you’re asking someone for their help. 

8. Accept Loss as Part of the Process 

Making a choice will cause a loss of some kind. You might have to let one job opportunity go to pursue another. You’ll give up some financial security if you leave your bad relationship, even if it’s safer and emotionally better for you. 

It’s an easy mistake to think that making the right choice will fill you with happiness. So if thinking about both choices stirs up feelings of sadness or doubt, are you doomed to be unhappy no matter what you do? Probably not. 

Loss is a normal part of the decision-making process and doesn’t mean you’ve made a bad choice. You may even feel some grief over the choice you’ve had to let go. This can feel uncomfortable, but it’s all normal. Accepting a state of mixed feelings can help you stick with your decision and minimize doubt.

Make Hard Choices Easier to Live With

If you wrote a letter to your future self, you’d have the wisdom to share about making tough decisions. These kinds of choices are always easier to understand when looking through the rear-view mirror. In many cases, hard decisions feel that way because we are hard on ourselves.

We allow our emotions and mental habits to take over. With some guidance and a fresh perspective, your next hard choice can be easier to live with.


Sources

  1. Pan, Pan. “Four Principles for Making Better Decisions.” INSEAD, September 4, 2014, knowledge.insead.edu/blog/insead-blog/four-principles-for-making-better-decisions-3555
  2. Rich, Mollie. “Throwing good money after bad – Why We Fall Victim to the Sunk Cost Fallacy and How to Beat It.”  Colby.edu CogBlog, April 21, 2017, web.colby.edu/cogblog/2017/04/21/throwing-good-money-after-bad-why-we-fall-victim-to-the-sunk-cost-fallacy-and-how-to-beat-it/
  3. “Ruth Chang: How Can Making Hard Choices Empower Us?” NPR, March 10, 2017, www.npr.org/transcripts/519269147

Icons sourced from FlatIcon.